Skip to main content Skip to footer content

Transmission Repair and Replacement in Appleton, WI | Transmission Repair Near You

From minor repairs to full replacements, our ASE-certified technicians provide expert transmission services to keep your vehicle running smoothly in Appleton, WI.

Schedule Appointment

Your Trusted Experts for Transmission Repair in Appleton, WI

At Matthews Tire, your trusted auto repair shop in Appleton, we know how stressful transmission issues can be. That’s why we’re here to make sure your vehicle is back on the road as quickly and smoothly as possible. With locations across Northeast Wisconsin, our ASE-certified technicians are committed to providing top-quality transmission repair in Appleton. Whether it’s strange noises, slipping gears or a complete breakdown, we’ll keep you rolling.

Schedule an Appointment

Providing top-quality, high-value car maintenance and auto repair services in Appleton, Menasha, Waupaca, Fond du Lac and Green Bay.

Schedule Appointment

What Are the Signs That Your Transmission Needs Repair?

Spotting transmission trouble early can save you time and money. Here’s what to watch for:

  • Difficulty shifting gears: Experiencing hesitation or refusal when changing gears.
  • Strange noises: Hearing grinding, clunking or whining? These sounds often point to transmission issues.
  • Slipping gears: Your car unexpectedly changes gears or struggles to maintain the current gear.
  • Delayed engagement: A noticeable pause when shifting from park to drive or reverse.
  • Fluid leaks: Look for red or sweet-smelling fluid under your car.
  • Burning smell: This can mean your transmission is overheating.

If any of these issues sound familiar, don’t wait; schedule a diagnostic check today. Early action prevents bigger and costlier problems.

Schedule Your Transmission Inspection

What’s the Difference Between Transmission Repair and Replacement?

At Matthews Tire, we believe in helping you make informed decisions about your vehicle. Here’s a quick breakdown:

  • Repair: Fixing specific parts like sensors, seals or gears. Repairs are faster and more affordable for minor issues.
  • Replacement: Installing a rebuilt or new transmission. Necessary when damage is extensive or the unit is beyond repair.

Our ASE-certified technicians will always recommend the best solution for your vehicle, ensuring it aligns with your needs and budget.

Common Transmission Problems

Understanding what’s happening under the hood can give you peace of mind. Here are a few common issues that can lead to transmission problems:

  • Low fluid levels: Leads to overheating or gear problems.
    Solution: Refill or flush transmission fluid.
  • Worn-out gears: Causes grinding or difficulty shifting.
    Solution: Replace damaged gears.
  • Faulty sensors: Affects automatic transmissions.
    Solution: Recalibrate or replace sensors.
  • Clutch trouble: Common in manual transmissions.
    Solution: Adjust or replace the clutch.

Our skilled technicians use advanced tools to identify the issue and make precise repairs.

Schedule Your Transmission Repair

Can You Drive with Transmission Problems?

It’s tempting to keep driving when you notice something wrong. However, a slipping transmission or delayed engagement can lead to:

  • Increased Damage: A slipping transmission can cause further wear and tear, leading to costly repairs.
  • Sudden Loss of Power: Risky, especially on busy roads like Richmond Street in Appleton, WI.
  • Higher Repair Costs: What starts as a minor issue could turn into a major expense.

We recommend scheduling a repair as soon as you notice an issue. Waiting often turns a minor repair into a major expense.

Why Choose Our Transmission Repair Shop in Appleton, WI?

We’re more than a repair shop—we’re part of the Appleton community. Here’s why locals trust us for transmission repairs, windshield repairs, and more in Appleton, WI.

  • Expert technicians: With automotive experience since 1952, we can handle all makes and models, from vintage cars to luxury SUVs.
  • Transparent pricing: No hidden fees, just clear, honest estimates.
  • State-of-the-art tools: Modern diagnostic equipment ensures we fix it right the first time.
  • Local convenience: With locations across Northeast Wisconsin, we understand the unique needs of Wisconsin drivers.

Whether it’s a quick fluid change or a full rebuild, we treat every vehicle with care. At Matthews Tire, we’re proud to deliver the same exceptional service that’s kept Appleton drivers rolling for over 70 years.

Schedule Your Transmission Repair

How Often Should You Change Transmission Fluid?

Think of transmission fluid as your transmission’s lifeblood. It keeps parts lubricated and prevents overheating. Most manufacturers recommend changing transmission fluid every 30,000 to 60,000 miles. For some vehicles, synthetic fluids allow for even longer intervals. Whether you’re navigating the busy streets near the Fox River Mall or heading out to High Cliff State Park, keeping your fluid fresh ensures smooth performance. Not sure what your car needs? Our team can help you stay on schedule.

Reliable Transmission Repair in Appleton

At Matthews Tire, we’re dedicated to keeping drivers rolling throughout Northeast Wisconsin. Whether it’s a quick repair or a complete replacement, our expert technicians deliver high-quality service with a personal touch. With convenient locations on W. College Avenue and Van Roy Road, we’re here to serve Appleton’s drivers.

Contact us today to schedule your appointment and experience the Matthews Tire difference!

Schedule Your Transmission Repair

Frequently Asked Transmission Repair Questions

What is the most common cause of transmission failure?

The leading cause of transmission failure is overheating, often due to:

  • Low or contaminated fluid: inadequate lubrication and cooling.
  • Neglected maintenance: failing to perform regular fluid changes and inspections.

Regular maintenance is essential to prevent such issues.

How long do transmissions last?
With proper maintenance, transmissions can last between 150,000 to 200,000 miles. Regular servicing and addressing issues early contribute to a longer lifespan.
Can a damaged transmission be repaired?
Yes, many transmission issues can be repaired, especially when identified early. Timely intervention can prevent minor problems from escalating into major failures.
Is it cheaper to repair or replace a transmission?

The cost-effectiveness of repairing versus replacing a transmission depends on the extent of the damage:

  • Minor Issues: Addressing small problems early can often be resolved with repairs, which are generally less expensive.
  • Major Damage: Severe issues may necessitate a complete replacement, which can be more costly.
How long will a repaired transmission last?
The longevity of a repaired transmission varies based on factors such as the quality of the repair, the vehicle’s age and adherence to maintenance schedules. A well-executed repair, combined with regular maintenance, can extend the transmission’s lifespan significantly.
Is it worth fixing a transmission in an older car?

Deciding whether to repair a transmission in an older vehicle involves considering the following:

  • Vehicle’s overall condition: Assessing the state of other major components.
  • Repair costs vs. vehicle value: Comparing the repair expenses to the car’s market value.

Consulting with a trusted mechanic can help determine the most cost-effective approach.

Is a rebuilt transmission as good as new?
A rebuilt transmission involves replacing worn or damaged components, which can restore functionality. While it may not be equivalent to a brand-new unit, a professionally rebuilt transmission can perform reliably and extend the vehicle’s service life.
Tire line up on a rack

Customer Testimonials

Hear from our many satisfied customers in Northeast Wisconsin. Learn why so many drivers trust their vehicles, tires and safety on the road with Matthews Tire.

Found a large screw in my tire yesterday during work! Went directly to Matthews Tire, where I bought them over a year ago. They had the tire fixed and I was back on the road in an hour! No charge, tire repair is free with purchase! Made my day!

— Tammie Juno

Appleton, WI

The service from Matthews was exceptional! I had a lug nut that I couldn’t get off and the service mechanic got it off and replaced right away. The cost was much lower than what I was prepared to pay. Awesome service and I will get my next tires from Matthew’s for sure!

— Dan Quaintance

Appleton, WI

Always a pleasure to visit Matthews! They were friendly and quick. They were able to give me an appointment when I needed it when I called a week ahead of time. I arrived right on time and they took care of my needs within 45 min! (Oil change and tire rotation)

— Davina Greene

Appleton, WI

While traveling (SC to WI), experienced loss of air pressure in front left tire and took to Matthews Tire. Found that I had a nail through the sidewall which precluded repair. As such had to replace all four tires due to Subaru requirements; after finding the right tires, Matthew's mounted, balanced, and installed per specification... appreciate the service and would highly recommend for future tire services.

— Michael Eanes

Appleton, WI

Great experience as always. Been coming here for over 23 years and never disappointed. Extremely thorough and friendly and knowledgeable staff and won’t be going anywhere else for the foreseeable future.

— Ryan Van Dyn Hoven

Appleton, WI

They got me in right away to fix my suspension that was hanging on by a prayer. They identified a structural safety concern and rectified that. The Jeep rides like new and actually stays pointed down the road true because of the work they did.

— Justin Weber

Appleton, WI

Excellent customer service experience with Patrick. Less than 24 hours from quote to installation. A pleasant experience from beginning to end. Will definitely use for my next tire purchase.

— Ron Hardwick

Appleton, WI

Read more testimonials and hear in-depth customer feedback on the customer stories page.

Customer Stories

Experience Auto Excellence

Never settle for subpar, overpriced auto services ever again! The ASE-certified technicians at Matthews Tire are here to bring you world-class service, dealer-level auto parts and unbeatable value on every service.

From tire installations, oil changes and alignments to full-service brake repairs, engine overhauls and more, we’ll keep you rolling.

Schedule Appointment
Happy family driving in a car together
Truck driving down snow covered country road

Winter Blues Tire Sale - $50 Off Select Four-Tire Purchase

Now through Friday, March 28, you can enjoy $50 off the purchase of a set of four tires from Goodyear, Kelly, Continental, General, Michelin or BFGoodrich. Get the traction and confidence you need for Wisconsin’s winter roads. Stop in or schedule your appointment today!

Buy Now